WordPress Customizing the ‘Continue with’

Last updated 07/11/2025

Within the Bread & Butter WordPress plugin, you can customize the Bread & Butter ‘Continue with’ tool, including its position, success message, theme, header, and custom authentication prompt text. These settings can be changed globally for all pages, or individually in the page editor.

Please note that page level settings take precedence over global settings on the ‘Continue with’ tool page. You can find the Bread & Butter page level setting by clicking the Bread & Butter logo at the top right when editing a post or page, or by clicking on the Options button, and selecting Bread & Butter under Plugins.

Global Customization

The global settings can be found by following these steps.

  1. In the left menu in WordPress Admin, click on Bread & Butter.



  2. In the left menu, expand More Tools and select ‘Continue with’ Tool.

‘Continue with’ Position

You can adjust the position of the ‘Continue with’ tool to better align with your content. The Margin creates space above and below, or to the left and right, of the popover.

  1. Set the vertical position and the top and bottom margins of the ‘Continue with’.

  2. Set the horizontal position and the left and right margins of the “Continue with’.


‘Continue with’ Popup delay

Next, you can choose how many seconds before the ‘Continue with’ appears on the page. If you want to to appear immediately, leave it blank.

‘Continue with’ Success Message

Next, you can set a custom success message that your visitors will see after signing in. You can also set how long it displays for the visitor, before it disappears:

After signing in, your visitors will see this:

Note: The default ‘success message seconds’ value is 5, if you leave it blank.

Hide ‘Continue with’ for returning users

If you only want users to sign in the first time they visit, check this box. When enabled, returning users won’t be bothered with the ‘Continue with’ and asked to sign in again. Enable this if you’re just interested in lead generation.

‘Continue with’ Header

Next, you can adjust the text that appears at the very top of the continue with, for several different states. The “New User” text is displayed when the user is brand new to your site, and you don’t have their email address or information yet. The “Returning User” text is displayed to people who have signed in previously, and have come back to your site.

You can also set a Display Name on the General Settings page, and then have that used in this header. If you have a Display name set, then the “Display Name Set” versions of the text are displayed. If you have no Display Name set, then the “no Display Name set” versions of the text are displayed.

Currently, %APP_NAME% is the only available parameter.


Authentication Prompt – Sign in Tool

Finally, you can choose to blur the web page when the ‘Continue with’ is displayed. See the Authentication Prompt per page setup below for enabling this feature. Customize the default text in the paragraph fields to direct customers. The “Expand label” text is used to prompt users to read more information in a third paragraph.


Button Style

At the bottom of the General Settings page, you can select Icons or Tiles to display the identity provider or single sign-on options.


Per Page Customization

The per page settings can be found by following these steps.

  1. Open the page or post where you want to customize the Bread & Butter ‘Continue with’ tool.

  2. Click the Bread & Butter logo at the top right, or click on the Options button, and selecting Bread & Butter under Plugins.



‘Continue with’ Position & Success Message

You can adjust the position of the ‘Continue with’ tool to better align with your content. The Margin creates space above and below, or to the left and right, of the popover.

  1. Set the vertical position and the top and bottom margins of the ‘Continue with’.

  2. Set the horizontal position and the left and right margins of the “Continue with’.

  3. Set any of the success message fields, if you want this page to have a different success message content than what you set globally on the Display Settings tab.


Authentication Prompt

You can choose to blur the web page when the ‘Continue with’ is displayed. Customize the default text in the paragraph fields to direct customers. The “Expand label” text is used to prompt users to read more information in a third paragraph.


Button Style

Select Icons or Tiles under Advanced Settings to display the identity provider or single sign-on options.


Next Steps

For global changes on the ‘Display Settings tab ‘Continue with’ page, click “Save” anywhere on the page to save your changes.

For per page customization, click the “Publish” button to publish your post or page.

The ‘Continue with’ is now configured for your WordPress website.


Don’t use Bread & Butter? Want to learn more about how Bread & Butter solves the four biggest problems facing marketers today? Book a demo and see how Bread & Butter is helping marketers make the most of their first-party data